← Research
Research paper

The Shape of Synchrony

Testing a superposition picture of social influence in group heart data

Individuals, Dr. Norbert Schwarzer writes, radiate influence in sphere-like waves that superpose into apparent plane waves. Three public datasets ask whether hearts in a group carry that signature, and whether anything beyond a shared rhythm is needed to explain it

November 2026 · 12 pages · PDF

An exploratory analysis of public heart recordings with correlation and recurrence methods, the latter developed by Dr. Charles Jorgensen, former Chief Neuro Scientist at NASA Ames. Motivated by Dr. Norbert Schwarzer’s posts on X. Any error is the author’s.

Cover: conceptual illustration.
Cover: conceptual illustration.

Abstract

Background. In a post on X on 9 November 2026, Dr. Norbert Schwarzer wrote that in societies “single individuals or even groups of the latter are radiating their influence to the environment (rest of the society) in multidimensional sphere-like waves,” which can be “superposed to globally appearing (and acting) as apparent plane waves” [1]. We derived three testable signatures of this picture for physiology, namely coupling between group members, a group-wide mode, and the absence of a consistent leader, and tested them in heart recordings.

Methods. Three public datasets, each recording every member of a group at the same time, provided four settings:

Each setting was compared with a chance baseline. For the decision groups, each real group was compared with 100 pseudo-groups assembled from people in other groups who never met. For the choir, bass trio and surgical team, each recording was compared with 200 time-shifted copies of itself, which keep each heart’s own rhythm but break the timing between people. Synchrony was measured in four ways: mean pairwise correlation (coupling), the share of variation carried by one group-wide pattern (global mode), cross-recurrence rate and determinism (shared patterns over time), and a lag-based score for whether one member’s changes come first (leadership).

Results. Each setting was tested for the three signatures: coupling, a group-wide mode, and the absence of a leader.

Conclusions. Hearts in a group can synchronize with no single member leading. In these data, however, strong synchrony appeared only in the choir, where the singers shared an outside rhythm: the music they were performing. Where no such shared rhythm existed, in the decision groups and the surgical team, synchrony was weak or absent. Because a shared outside rhythm can produce synchrony by itself, these datasets cannot show whether people also influence one another directly. The proposed experiment tests the account that shared coherence arises when music or movement, a shared emotional experience and aligned intent come together, varying each of the three to measure what it contributes.

Status. This is an exploratory analysis of public data; measures were chosen with the hypothesis in mind but were not registered in advance. Dr. Schwarzer’s posts on X motivated the work, and the recurrence methods follow Dr. Jorgensen. Any error is the author’s.

Key results

Only the choir met all three signatures; the decision groups met the first, weakly (Table 2).

Table 2. The three signatures by setting. Comparisons are with time-shifted copies for continuous recordings and with pseudo-groups for the decision groups; p-values as in Section 4.4.
SettingCouplingGlobal modeLeader
Choir, 9 singers, 69 min Strong: mean correlation 0.09 vs 0.00 in shifted copies (p < 0.005); 40% of one-minute windows synchronized vs 5% expected Yes: 31% of variation vs 28% (p < 0.005) None reliable: most frequent leader in 19% of windows vs 16% by chance
Bass trio, rehearsal, 4.7 min Strong: 0.27 vs 0.00 (p = 0.02) Yes: 56% vs 48% (p < 0.005) Too short to judge
Bass trio, performance, 4.7 min None: −0.09 vs 0.01 No (p = 0.21) Too short to judge
32 decision groups, 5 min each Weak: mean rank 64th percentile; 72% of groups above the median (p = 0.02) No: 54th percentile (p = 0.42) None: 45th percentile (p = 0.43)
Surgical team, 3, 116 min None: −0.002 vs −0.001; 5% of windows, as chance predicts No (p = 0.15) None

In the choir, synchrony came in bursts lasting one to a few minutes, reaching mean pairwise correlations of 0.4 to 0.5, separated by stretches at chance level (Figure 2). Across 137 windows, the singer who most often led did so in 19% of them, close to the 16% expected if leadership were assigned at random; with overlapping windows this does not identify a leader.

In the decision groups, real groups ranked above their pseudo-groups on second-to-second co-fluctuation more often than chance (mean rank 64, Wilcoxon p = 0.02), but not on the global mode or leadership (Figure 3). Cross-recurrence rate (p = 0.92) and determinism (p = 0.76) did not separate real from pseudo-groups, most likely because heart rate sampled every 2 s is too coarse for recurrence structure. The direction of the coupling result agrees with the original study [7].

Reference

[1] N. Schwarzer, “Towards a Mathematical Proof of Heaven: How does God change the world without showing his hand? Part II,” post on X (@Dr_N_Schwarzer), 9 November 2026. x.com/Dr_N_Schwarzer

Library
Papers & briefs
→